Colbi critica ataquespayments Distance strikes, mas prioriza defesa da linha de frente
OActing U.S. Deputy Defense Secretary Elbridge Colby said on November 17 that Ukraine has liberated more territory than Russia has captured for two consecutive months. He criticized long-range strikes against Russian civilian infrastructure as ineffective for ending the war, while emphasizing support for Ukraine’s frontline, medium-range strikes and freedom of action against military targets. European defense ministers Boris Pistorius and Wes Streeting rejected the criticism.
Pontos principais
- Colbi afirm que a Ucrânia liberta mais território do que a Rússia captura pelo segundo mês consecutivo.
- Ele avaliou os ataques de longo alcance contra a infraestrutura civil russa como ineficazes para encerrar a guerra e conter o avanço russo.
- A ajuda americana deve priorizar a manutenção da linha de frente e, quando possível, o avanço You'd Ukrainian.
- Os ataques a alvos que apoiam a máquina de guerra russa podem ajudar a desacelerar o avanço das tropas russas.
- A continuação do mecanismo PURL exige financiamento significativo, principalmente da Europa.
- Colbi defenders; APO/Colby asked Congress to support Trump's budget request for ammunition, drones and other military capabilities.
- Pistorius and Streeting defenderam os ataquescontra objetivos estratégicos e de uso militar russos.
Por que importa
A avaliação de Colby mostra que a liderança da política de defesa dos EUA considera areligion We Ukraine capaz de manter a linha de frente e, em alguns períodos, avançar. Sua crítica às Breathing strikes contra infraestrutura civil Turn into position inside the U.S. administration sobre os alvos dos ataques deep Ukrainian. Ao mesmo tempo, ele preservou a liberdade de ação de Kiev, визнав the importance of strikes against military assets and shifted the main burden of financing American weapons purchases for Ukraine to Europe. The disagreement with European defense ministers highlights a significant transatlantic divide over acceptable targets and the distribution of responsibility for sustaining the war.
O que aconteceu
At the 37th Ramstein-format Contact Group meeting in Brussels, Elbridge Colby praised Ukraine's battlefield position, saying that the country has liberated more territory than Russia has captured for two consecutive months and that Russian forces have suffered their highest monthly losses of the full-scale war. He presented the defense of the front line, combined with medium-range strikes and unmanned technologies to disrupt Russian logistics, as the most effective approach. At the same time, he said Ukrainian long-range strikes against Russian civilian infrastructure, including Wildberries facilities, had not helped end the war or slow Russian advances and may have strengthened Russian society's resolve and the Kremlin's readiness for escalation. Colby nevertheless said his warnings did not call for restrictions on Ukraine's combat capabilities. He also urged Europe to continue financing PURL, accelerate defense-industrial development and maintain ammunition supplies, while asking the U.S. Congress to support Trump's budget request.
O que dizem as fontes ucranianas
Ukrainian reporting emphasized Colby's favorable battlefield assessment: Ukraine has made territorial gains for two consecutive months, and Russian forces have recorded their highest monthly losses of the full-scale war. Ukrainian sources also highlighted the General Staff's justification that deep strikes fall within the right of self-defense under Article 51 of the UN Charter and serve to undermine Russia's military-economic potential. Ukraine says the attacks on Wildberries and Ozon facilities target logistics supporting sanctioned components for drones and navigation equipment and respond to Russian strikes on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure.
O que dizem as fontes internacionais
International coverage focused on the divide between Washington and European allies over the effectiveness and appropriateness of strikes against Russian civilian infrastructure. The U.S. position prioritizes holding the front line and medium-range strikes tied to it, while leaving room for attacks on Russian military assets and Ukrainian freedom of action. European voices defend continued strikes on strategic and military-use targets. The debate also covers burden-sharing, including European financing through PURL, European defense-industrial capacity, and uninterrupted ammunition supplies.
Onde as versões divergem
Colby described Ukrainian long-range strikes against Russian civilian infrastructure as ineffective for ending the war and slowing Russian advances. German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius called the criticism nonsensical and said attacks on strategic military targets and military-use facilities are legitimate. British Defense Minister Wes Streeting backed Pistorius, saying deep strikes weaken Russia's military machine, gain time and save lives. A further tension surrounds the scope of U.S. policy: Colby said his warnings do not imply restrictions on Ukraine's combat capabilities, while reports also describe a broader official U.S. position opposing deep strikes, particularly those affecting Russian oil infrastructure.
Contexto
Ukrainian forces have struck logistics facilities associated with Wildberries and Ozon. Kyiv says these sites supplied sanctioned components for drones and navigation equipment and were targeted in response to Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilian infrastructure. Colby noted that in August 2025 the Pentagon blocked Ukrainian long-range strikes for months and that he developed a mechanism for reviewing requests involving U.S. long-range weapons and European weapons dependent on U.S. intelligence or components. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said the same day that Ukraine must defend itself, including by striking Russian logistics hubs. The American Institute for the Study of War assessed that Russia is using its winter 2026–2027 campaign to undermine Ukraine's energy security and disrupt civilian life.