Publicado em · Atualizado em

Kushner diz que EUA convinceu Rússia a aceitar garantias de segurança para a Ucrânia inspiradas na artigo 5 da NATO

Em Berlim, Jared Kushner afirmou que os Estados Unidosuccessfully convincing Russia to accept a concept of security guarantees for Ukraine based on principles similar to Article 5 of the NATO Charter. Donald Trump is open to considering such guarantees if they align with US interests and are approved by Congress, while President Volodymyr Zelensky says it is unclear whether the parties share the same understanding of the proposed mechanism.

Pontos principais

  • On November 19, 2026, Kushner said in Berlin that Washington had persuaded Russia to accept the concept of guarantees inspired by Article 5 of NATO.
  • Trump agreed to consider guarantees for Ukraine if they serve US interests, and tasked Kushner and Steve Witkoff with preparing proposals.
  • Kushner acknowledged substantial skepticism and distrust in Russia toward Article 5-style guarantees.
  • The US says Russia agreed to participate in a multilateral negotiating format involving European countries.
  • Zelensky said he is not sure that Ukraine and the US have the same understanding of the proposed guarantees.
  • According to Zelensky, the mechanism should clearly define partners' response to a new Russian attack and remain understandable to Ukrainian society, businesses and investors.
  • Any US agreement would have to be coordinated with Ukraine and Europe, approved by Congress and fit into a broader security framework.

Por que importa

O modelo proposto poderá determinar se os Estados Unidos e seus parceiros fornecerão uma resposta automática ou vinculante a um futuro ataque russo contra a Ucrânia. A posição de Trump abre caminho paraeldegarantias concretas, embora nenhum acordo final tenha sido anunciado. Qualquer garante americana precisará da aprovação do Congresso e deverá integrar uma arquitetura mais ampla de segurança, enquanto as diferenças de entendimento entre Kyiv e Washington ускладнюють as negociações.

O que aconteceu

Ao final de uma reunião da Coalizão de Vontade em Berlim, Jared Kushner disse que os Estados Unidos convenceram a Rússia a aceitar a ideia de garantias de segurança para a Ucrânia baseadas em princípios semelhantes ao artigo 5 da Carta da NATO. Trump concordou em considerar a proposta e encarregou Kushner e Steve Witkoff de preparar alternativas. Segundo Kushner, a Rússia também aceitou participar de um formato multilateral de negociação com países europeus. As propostas ainda não foram concluídas: devem abranger mecanismos de стимулів, controle, deterrência e consequências por violação, além de passar pelo Congresso norte-americano.

O que dizem as fontes ucranianas

A coberturaAKE ucraína contrastou a promessa americana de um mecanismo semelhante ao artigo 5 com as dúvidas de Zelensky sobre seu conteúdo concreto. Os relatos nfocaram a possível presença de tropas e bases estrangeiras na Ucrânia, a resposta negativa de Washington sobre a presença militar americana e a necessidade de regras claras para a reação a uma nova agressão. Zelensky também、速 consider membership NATO the strongest guarantee of security for Ukraine and Europe, while EU membership itself as a guarantee, and argued that any mechanism must be clear to Ukrainian society, business and investors.

O que dizem as fontes internacionais

A posição apresentada por Washington передбачає broader security framework, including arrangements within the Coalition of the Willing, multi-layered defense, deterrence mechanisms and communication channels. Trump’s openness is conditional on US interests and Congressional approval, while participation by Ukraine and Europe is presented as necessary to avoid unilateral decisions.

Onde as versões divergem

Kushner characterized Russia’s acceptance as a major breakthrough and said Washington had persuaded Moscow to adopt the Article 5-style concept. However, this was his claim rather than a separately confirmed Russian position, and he also acknowledged significant Russian skepticism and distrust. Zelensky additionally questioned whether Ukraine, the United States and NATO allies shared the same understanding of what such guarantees would entail.

Contexto

Article 5 of the NATO Charter treats an armed attack on one or more allies as an attack on all allies, although each state independently determines the assistance it provides. US and Ukrainian talks in Kyiv in September 2025 reached what Kushner called a dead end, but negotiations resumed through a trilateral format involving Europe. On November 12, Kushner and Witkoff met Zelensky and European national security advisers in Dublin before the November 19 Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, which brought together nearly 40 delegations, mostly led by heads of state or government.